Sheet Pan Half Size - 12-7/8'' x 17-3/4'' Heavy Duty, 13 Gauge
|
List Price: Our Price: $21.50 You Save: $8.49 (28%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Category: Home See more product details |
|---|
Tools and Hardware Reviews of Sheet Pan Half Size - 12-7/8'' x 17-3/4'' Heavy Duty, 13 Gauge
Customer Review: Quality drops after outsourcing
Summary: 1 Stars
I purchased four of these a year or so ago after reading a recommendation for them in Cook's Illustrated. They are beautiful - smooth, sturdy, no flaws in design at all, and priced reasonably. I ordered an additional one recently, same brand, same model, and the rims are rolled under and open instead of rolled under completely. The edges of the rolled rims on the new pan are sharp. Food and oils can collect under the rims and it would take a very small brush or pipe cleaner to keep clean. The pan feels cheaper. I returned it. The first four were made in Fort Wayne, Indiana. The recent one was made in China.Customer Review: Severely Disappointed!! Buyer Beware! Pan Warps. Overpriced. Not Dishwasher Safe. May Be Toxic.
Summary: 1 Stars
I usually don't write reviews, unless I feel strongly for or against a product.
This is the first time Cook's Illustrated botched up a recommendation/review. After reading their review, I was so excited to buy pans that would not warp. I bought 2 from [...] ([...]) for [...]. So I thought I got a great deal.
Not.
The first time I put it under the broiler, the pan warped. When I put it in the dishwasher, it discolored. Not Dishwasher safe.
After learning my lesson about the dishwasher, I left my pans soaking in the sink. Unfortunately, the pans discolored badly, turning the pan a dark brown color (unevenly). I think it may have oxidized with something in the sink. I've *read* that if aluminum reacts to acidic food, it could be toxic. However, I don't know if this is true, so buyer beware.
And for those cynics out there....I did buy the right pans. After heavy research to confirm the pan is indeed the one recommended by CI, including going to Lincoln Foodservice website ([...]), model number 5314 is the only 13 gauge aluminum pan made by Lincoln Foodservice [...]).
Bottom Line: Overpriced pans did not deliver. Pan warps, is not dishwasher safe, and may be toxic (due to oxidation). The search is still on for non-warping, non-reactive half sheet pans.
--if you find this review helpful, please rate it so. That way others will be able to find it and read it too.
Customer Review: Sheet Pan
Summary: 5 Stars
This half sheet pan exceeded my expectations. It does not warp and parchment paper fits into the pan nicely. Only wish I had ordered 2.Customer Review: Sheet Pan Half Size
Summary: 5 Stars
Pan arrived quickly and works well. Very pleased with product. It is the second one I purchased. Love how it cleans up so easily.Customer Review: Sheet pan
Summary: 4 Stars
Like others who bought this item based upon the Cook's Illustrated recommendation, the pan warped at its first use! Other than that, it is sturdy and good, just permanently warped!